From my friend TS comes this work of satirical whimsy from Disputations:
Hello. I'm here to abduct your family and sell them into slavery. Now, I know that many people, people of good will, believe this is wrong. I understand that, and I respect their opinion. At the same time, many others are equally convinced of the need for slaves, particularly when our own government can't guarantee that hard-working families will have time to clean their own houses. For my own part, I have thought long and hard about this difficult issue, an issue that doesn't admit of simple answers. And I've come to the decision that the right thing for me to do is to be a slaver. But a new kind of slaver, one who does not vilify those who disagree.
That's just too good.
Need
‘So you see it was like this You see I was down yes yes I know I was down but...You see it was like this I had to keep going because I knew I just knew it was the right day the only day...A flush a straight you name it I was going to finally take it all and even Rob with the Big Blind didn't scare me...So you see it was like that and then it happened that the game ended and I still owed 'em a bit was still a bit down still down you see but not out no not out not like that loser Gilbert with his damned horse that was sure to place but didn't even show no not like that...The number looks worse than it actually is...All those zeros...zeros and the interest don't forget that interest they really screw you with interest these guys...But it's not that bad not that bad at all...It's just that...How how the hell did he throw down an ace an ace dammit where did it come from thought I'd kept track thought I knew just where...So many zeros...But it's not that bad not that bad really it's not...So you see it's like this...um...I need...you see...you know...it's like this...I've got to get him back just got to get him back but there's no way without...you see...what I need is...need...'
With this he trailed off into silence at last, silence and stillness, for he had been fidgeting about as he spoke, fidgeting and gesturing and swirling his cigarette about so that God help me one wrong move and I would have gotten hot ash in my eye. I had seen him unhinged before, but never quite like this. I couldn't get him to tell me just what the hell had happened. All I knew was that he showed up at my house with a look of wild panic in his eyes. He had lost. He had lost big. I had no idea how big until he finally threw himself on the couch and said
‘They've got him they've got him I had to leave him had no choice...Promised ‘em that I would get the money promised ‘em but now they've got him they've got Tony...'
I felt the blood drain from my face.
‘Yes yes my son my son...They have him...Security you know make me keep my promise I promised...'
I sat back and yelled, ‘What the fuck did you do?!'
He looked over at me, helpless.
‘Lost him Lost my son Have to get him back But I promised I promised...'
He trailed off again repeating under his breath that ugly word ‘promised' - promised whom? I asked him, ‘What did you promise, exactly?'
‘Promised to pay Promised to pay.'
He sat up and looked vacantly about the room.
‘What will they do if I don't if I can't What will they do Jesus Jesus Why did I leave him Why did I leave him...'
‘From the beginning,' I said, ‘Start from the beginning and tell me what happened. Calm the hell down and tell me everything.'
Shaking and sweating, smoking without let, he told his tale.
He had flown with a friend to Vero Beach to play cards. This was the kind of friend Bill somehow had in abundance - gold nugget pendant and ring, Cuban cigars, a wad of cash in a money clip from God knows where. This one happened to own a Cessna. Go figure. Because Tony so loved to fly, and had never been in one of those small private planes, Bill had taken him along for the adventure of it all.
The players met in a mobile home of all things. The mobile home park itself was just a block from the beach. He had given Tony a wad of bills and had left him outside to fend for himself. The game lasted something like twelve hours. Bill already owed them a lot of money, but hoped to more than recoup his losses this time. Things had, mirabile dictu, gone to hell, and he had lost more and more until, by the end of the day, he had done the unthinkable - he had left his son as collateral to ensure that the money would be there. He was given three days.
That was last night. His friend had flown him back to the airport in St Pete, and Bill had driven, all wired and loopy, straight to my house.
Joy.
I asked at last, ‘How much do you owe?'
‘How much how much Owe...What?'
‘How much to do you owe?'
‘Uh...oh...you know...'
‘No, I don't know, that's why I'm asking again, how much do you fucking owe these guys?'
He mumbled and fidgeted and made it difficult to hear.
‘87...something like that...owe...lots of zeros...so many zeros...owe...need...'
He started to ramble again, so I pinned him down. ‘Eighty-seven thousand fucking dollars??'
‘Give or take,' he said, in a moment of sudden, fleeting lucidity.
‘And what do you want me to do about it?'
He suddenly stood up and started pacing the room. He lit another cigarette. Eyes on the floor, he started in again.
‘What to do Yes what to do That's the question Good good need to think need to plan Came to you for help Need the money Need to get him back You have you have you have it all Look at this damn place You've got...got...need...'
I walked over and grabbed him by the arms and shouted, ‘You seriously think I'm just going to give you close to ninety grand? Like I just have it lying around so I can bale you out again and again? What the fuck is wrong with you?'
He wilted right there and started to sob. Cigarette smoke rose between us, ashes falling on his shoes.
‘I'm sorry I'm sorry So sorry...,' he sobbed as he rested his head on my shoulder.
‘Everything's going to be all right. We'll figure it out.'
‘Knew you would help...Help...Need...,' he sobbed all the more on my shoulder.
I pushed him away and sat him back down.
‘Still,' I said, ‘I just don't have that kind of money. We'll have to do something else.'
‘Anything anything anything...,' he said softly, rocking back and forth and smoking, always smoking.
‘Do you mean that?'
He said nothing, but kept rocking and smoking and mumbling to himself.
‘Bill! Stay with me! Do you really mean you'll do anything? This is important.'
He looked up at me, helpless, sad. Finally he said weakly
‘Yes anything anything anything Anything for the boy for Tony Anything for my son...'
‘Good. That's better. Now, why don't you go get cleaned up - you look like hell. You can sleep here on the couch. The rest'll be good for you. You'll need it tomorrow.'
‘Yes yes...Rest need rest...Need...'
While he was gone I opened my wall safe and took out all the cash I had, just in case. Next, I went round to the chest in the corner of the room, and after some hesitation opened it slowly, and searched under the blankets for my old .45.
I felt for the first time in many years the heft of the thing. Just then Bill stumbled into the room again and stopped fast, staring at me.
‘Don't worry about it,' I said, and gathered the blankets and a pillow and tossed them onto the couch. ‘Get some sleep,' I said. ‘We've got a long day tomorrow.'
I left him alone and closed myself in the garage and went to work. I gathered some tools - I had no idea just what I'd need, so I put together the whole kit, just like the old days. Moving to my work table, I took the pistol apart and cleaned and oiled it. I unlocked a drawer and pulled out several clips. It had been so long, so long since I had done any of this. God help me, it had been ten years if a day. Finally I took the old silencer down from the shelf over the table and cleaned it as well. For some reason I had left it there, in plain sight, amused I think that almost no one could possibly know what the hell it was.
I reassembled the pistol, passed an oiled cloth over every surface, then wrapped it and the silencer in a towel and packed them with the rest of my tools.
By the time I came in from the garage Bill was asleep, snoring and tossing on my couch. I sat up all night, patiently waiting for the dawn.
‘It's time,' I said as I woke him at six.
By six-thirty we were on the road. We arrived in the outskirts of Miami at nine-thirty or so. The man who had Tony kept a house on Key Biscayne, off Harbor Point, right there on the water. We waited until dusk to move. I got out at the entrance to the estates and left Bill with the car so I could walk along the waterfront in the dark. Well, I won't bore you with all the details, but God help me, it was easier than it should have been. There were only twelve of them. I found the boy in an upstairs bedroom - there was only one guy watching the door. Tony ran over and hugged me. He was so small, so vulnerable. ‘Where's my dad?' he asked. ‘Downstairs,' I said, and told him to stay put between the wall and the bed until I came for him.
As for the rest of the crew, I had little trouble with most of them. The worst was this one guy I had to drown in a bathroom sink, holding him under so he couldn't call out and ruin everything. He had taken me by surprise and knocked the pistol out of my hand. That wouldn't have happened in days gone by.
In the end, Bill and I were left standing. We had already taken Tony to the car and told him to wait. I went back inside to clean the place up, while Bill paced the great room smoking, as always endlessly smoking. When I finished, Bill and I stood alone in this moonlit room with a grand view of the Bay just beyond the pool. I had what felt like a couple of broken ribs and some bruises here and there that hurt like hell. Bill was, as always, unscathed.
‘We saved him we saved him...'
With that, he flashed me an idiot smile then took a drag on his cigarette.
‘Yes we did my friend,' I said.
‘Won't ever let anything happen to him...No, this is the last time...This is the bottom...The worst.'
‘The worst.'
‘Have to make it right...Have to show him...Have to...must...need...'
‘I know.'
He turned to look over the waters as they shimmered in the Florida night.
‘Beautiful isn't it?'
‘Sure is. Sure is.'
‘And I've got him back...Nothing going to happen to him now you'll see...I'll get it right, just you wait...Next time it'll be the right time...The right day the only day...I'll come out on top and all for him all for him all for my son.'
I hung my head. ‘I'm sure you will.'
‘Just love him, you know? Want him to be safe want him to be free...he's just got to...Want him...Want for him...'
He trailed off again, weeping and shaking, still turned away from me.
‘I know you do.'
‘I just can't...have to have...must...don't...,' he wiped his nose with his sleeve and continued, ‘I'll promise him promise him Has to have everything Never leave him again He'll be with me always Always my son I'm so sorry Never happen again...can't...want...need...'
‘Yes, I know.'
Then there was silence and stillness between us for a few minutes. At the last I said quietly ‘I'm sorry,' and shot him twice in the back of the head.
He fell forward without a sound. A light spray of his blood mingled on my clothes and hands with that of the other men I had killed that night. ‘Goodbye' was all I could say, like it mattered.
After washing the blood off my hands and arms and changing my shirt, I gathered all my tools and bagged my dirty clothes. Outside the night was still and clear. A warm breeze came off the water. Out of habit I took a long look around. The neighborhood was quiet. No one paid attention to a thing.
As I got in the car, Tony asked again ‘Where's my dad?' All I could tell him was that his father wouldn't be back for a very long time. The boy started to cry, so I held him for a while and said ‘Everything's going to be all right,' and I almost believed it. We had to get away, far away. I used the cash to get us all the right papers, and so we vanished for all the world knew.
Since then he's been mine to watch over and to protect. After a while, I told him that his father died saving him, and that's the God's honest truth of it after all. I mean, what else was there to do? Well, God help me, I'll teach him to be a man who won't do the sorts of things his father and I did.
God help me I will.
Once again, I'm having my doubts about this whole blogging thing. I really like it. I get to write prose for a change, there are some interesting folks about blogdom, and I always learn a lot. But, there is one small problem. I hate apologetics. Not just on the web, though compared to apologetics on the web what passes for commending the faith of the Church in real life looks like the Lost Works of John Chrysostom. No, I hate apologetics. It always, always, always, involves somehow misrepresenting someone else.
It's very difficult for me to be clear about what I mean, as I'm obviously not a wallflower when it comes to slamming someone's argument against the virtual wall. (More about that in a moment.) I have no problem with arguments, no, none at all. It's just that, to be blunt, most of us just don't know enough to make arguments in the first place. Most folks only know enough to say simply what they believe. When it comes to challenging others, however, most people are just ignorant. Lutherans attack Calvinists, for instance, and there is good reason, in confessional terms. But do Lutherans, particularly newbie Lutherans in love (again, for good reason) with their new-found home really know enough about the complexities and experiences of Reformed communions to say anything meaningful? And it goes the other way as well.
That's just an example. I guess what I'm getting at is that, well, not to put too fine a point on it - if you're going to do anything else than confess what your communion believes, then you'd better be learned and have wide experience. You'd better have wisdom, humility - not traits associated with new converts, or, well, with most of us. In short, I propose the following unreasonable standard: no one can really do apologetics unless they're insanely well-read, at least open to learning lots of languages, immersed in texts from a wide variety of traditions, and open to spending time in different congregations and parishes actually getting to know these people they would otherwise categorize. If there is a heresy to refute, then by all means do so. But take as your standard Irenaeus or Maximus, Thomas or Luther. In short, really know what the hell's going on, what's underneath the obvious letter of the heresy.
I suppose this is a call for nothing less than silence when we don't know enough to speak intelligently and charitably. Have I not read much of a controversial author, used by those in another communion to bolster their perhaps heretical claims? Well, I must name the heresy for what it is, but I can under no circumstances attack an author I have not read, nor should I make up easy dichotomies that seem to bolster my case, as if I knew everyone in every communion. In other words, a simple 'You're wrong, and here's why' will do, not 'Well, you Calvinists/ Lutherans/ Catholics/Palamites are all Iconoclasts/ Synergists/ Pagans/ Lunatics, and we all know this because you're from the West/ East/ Ireland/ Appalachians.'
So there. Only street-smart, wizened Christians known for deep scholarship, true empathy, and fierce devotion to the Truth should do apologetics, and the rest of us should get out of their way. What this means for blogging, though, is difficult to tell. Seems so many like to use this for apologetics, and to be honest I get fed up with the whole thing. And I really hate the 'You can't expect perfection' response, as though that were either possible or desirable. No, not perfection, but if you're going to do a job, do it with excellence. I guess this gets wearisome, and I long for some sign that we aren't all just talking in a meaningless circle to one another, each determined to win, and more important, each determined to make sure that someone loses. Meanwhile, suppose someone from outside Christian Blogdom does happen upon our little world. Will what they see and read truly commend the faith to 'em? Or will they think we're a bunch of snivelling know-nothings determined to win arguments at all costs? For those who want to do apologetics, I ask you, if even one person is scandalized by our stupidity and arrogance, was the battle worth it?
I don't know what the answer is, of course, only that the question bothers me. As I said, I enjoy this for many reasons, but if it ends up doing more harm than good, then why do it at all? Does all this blogging and reading blogs only encourage my own tendencies to argue ad hominem? I just don't know...

